Red.
It’s a Mormon Guitar first.
Merry Christmas, everyone.
Christmas isn’t the only reason I swapped the black shirt for the red one this month. So let’s dig into this month’s arrangement to find out why.
I’ve wanted to do O Come O Come Emmanuel for a long time. So long, in fact, that I’m not sure why I never sat down and worked it out before now. For me, it is the most spiritual and emotional Christmas hymn there is. And as we all know… emotion is my jam.™
Seriously though, if you can sing or listen to O Come O Come Emmanuel and not feel anything, you’re dead inside. It grabs everyone. It’s like the Comfortably Numb of hymns.
But there is something strangely different about this hymn compared to others that we sing. (Besides the fact that it is not actually in our current hymnbook)
It’s haunting. Extremely haunting.
“Wait a second… you just said it’s the most spiritual Christmas hymn for you. Now you’re telling me it’s dark? Spiritual music can’t be haunting or dark. Maybe you should just scratch this arrangement and instead give us a nice acoustic version of Scatter Sunshine…”
No. No… Nope.
Listen people. Music is a language. A physical language and a spiritual language. Powerful, uplifting music is everywhere, in all forms and styles, and I truly believe Heavenly Father is behind it, using it to bless his children. Music speaks to each of us differently the same way God speaks to each of us differently. So let’s all stop judging people based on their musical tastes. Turn off your brains and turn on your hearts.
Where was I… Oh yeah, O Come O Come Emmanuel.
One of the reasons the haunting melody is packed with emotion is because this hymn comes from medieval times. Right in the thick of the apostasy, when people felt lost, looking for hope.
Not a lot of reason to sing Scatter Sunshine back then.
The melody actually comes from a plainsong called Veni Emmanuel. Plainsongs were/are chants sung at church services in the early western Christian church. They’re monophonic, meaning they only have a a single melody line. No harmonies or accompaniment. (Kind of like monks singing gregorian chants. OK, exactly like monks singing gregorian chants.)
Now here is what I find so fascinating about O Come O Come Emmanuel. Even though it was written as a single melody line, when you start to apply some chords and harmonies to it, you start to see how deep and complex it really is. There is so much hidden behind that single melody line. It’s amazing.
Now with most modern pop music, you have maybe three or four chords used throughout the song. Any guitar player can tell you that. A lot of the time, you can go an entire verse, sometimes and entire song, with maybe one or two chord changes.
But when I started applying different harmonies to O Come O Come Emmanuel, I found it became a marathon of chord changes. For most of the first verse, I’m changing chords with every note of the melody.
That’s four chord changes per measure.
Each new note in the melody brought a new chord, a new voice, a new texture. And because it was written as a plainsong, every chord voicing you’ve ever heard of this song was just an interpretation by whomever did that arrangement. I feel like there is still so much more behind this simple melody, just waiting to be discovered and experienced.
Man, I love music.
Back to red shirt.
There’s a simple reason for the shirt. I wanted a black background for this song. With my black shirt, I quickly became two arms and a floating head playing the guitar. It’s a Christmas hymn so I swapped it for a red shirt. Problem solved.
I wanted to switch up the aesthetic of the video to go with the hymn. I don’t have drones for swooping aerial shots of me playing on top of Mt. Everest. I don’ t have a video crew. I don’t even have a video person. It’s just me. I just have a camera and a guitar. I hit record. I play. That’s all I can do. So changing the background color is pretty much the extent of my capabilities at the moment.
The black background is supposed to add to the whole medieval, Apostasy, haunting feeling of the hymn; A hymn about anxiously anticipating the coming of the Messiah to save Israel. Hoping for a brighter future.
But it’s specifically meant to lead into the third verse.
While I added different chords and harmonies to the first two verses, I decided to do the third verse as it was originally written.
As a true plainsong.
Just the melody.
Focused on emotion.
With reverb cranked to Basilica levels.
Played with just a whisper.
Looking for the light of hope.
Even when surrounded by complete darkness.
O come, O come, Emmanuel,
And ransom captive Israel,
That mourns in lonely exile here,
Until the Son of God appear.
Rejoice ! Rejoice ! Emmanuel
Shall come to thee, O Israel.
O come, Thou Rod of Jesse, free
Thine own from Satan’s tyranny ;
From depths of hell Thy people save,
And give them victory o’er the grave.
Rejoice ! Rejoice ! Emmanuel
Shall come to thee, O Israel.
O come, Thou Dayspring, from on high,
And cheer us by Thy drawing nigh;
Disperse the gloomy clouds of night,
And death’s dark shadows put to flight.
Rejoice ! Rejoice ! Emmanuel
Shall come to thee, O Israel.
LaVonna Barton
Posted at 22:46h, 02 DecemberInspiring!! My first love is the classical guitar. Electric guitar is much lower on the list. I have now changed my opinion. I also have adored the song “O Come, O Come Emanuel” and you have captured the true soul of the song. Thanks for sharing. I shall be looking for your album at Seagull Book.
Nathaniel Rogers
Posted at 09:29h, 21 DecemberWow!
I just love everything about this site. Oh, and song!
Vic Johnston
Posted at 16:38h, 04 JanuaryJust listened to O Come, O Come Emanuel. Don’t ask why I didn’t sooner. My loss. Like you, it has long been one of my favorite. Rather than calling it dark, I have always used the word “haunting”. Those minor tunes tend to lean that way but this is the most haunting tune I know of.
I listened. Usually I read your comments while I listen but I couldn’t draw myself away from the music to focus on words.
Then I read.
Then I listened again with greater appreciation.
You’re amazing on those guitars!
On another note, I received another Mormon Guitar CD for Christmas this year. Second year in a row that your CD topped my list of tangible Christmas gifts. (Will there be another for next Christmas?) Really enjoyed it. I especially like the revised version of “the Spirit of God”. The first version on your site rattled me a bit much.
My granddaughter who is currently staying with us couldn’t find her Celtic Women – Lullabies” cd she usually goes to sleep by so she borrowed “Tune My Heart”. I had to find her lullabies CD so I could reclaim my CD. It is awesome to relax and meditate to.
Love it.
Dick Carpenter
Posted at 10:59h, 07 AprilMy favorite Christmas song since I first heard it as a child. Your version is a master piece. One of the best I’ve heard. Your music touches me deeply. I relate completely. Got my first guitar at 15. Served in Brasil 68-70. Brought a de Giorgio student guitar home. Still play it cause the tone resonates in my soul. Can’t wait to hear more. Love the interactive feature.
Elder McEntire
Posted at 21:31h, 27 MayHi Ben!
I’m a missionary serving in Missouri, and a novice guitar player. I was a big rock and metal fan before I came on my mission. Anything from the 50’s to the 90’s was fair game, from the Beatles to Led Zeppelin to Metallica. As I came on my mission I acquired a guitar to keep my skills sharp, but I soon realized that to really focus on the mission I needed to step away from playing rock songs and focus more on spiritual stuff. This was a huge challenge for me. Most guitar hymn arrangements are classical or folk, and I’m not a huge fan of either. But then I had a companion that had one of your albums, and my world changed. He showed me your arrangement of “I Am a Child of God”, played on a strat and sounding like a Mormon Stevie Ray Vaughn, and it was amazing! I didn’t think it was possible to do a blues or rock cover of a hymn and still keep it spiritual and powerful, but you did it and you made it incredible! I’ve been listening to your songs ever since, and every new one is a treat. I absolutely love your electric arrangements, especially “O Come O Come Emmanuel”. The electric guitar sound brings some serious power and energy to these hymns that the acoustic can’t quite bring, and your arrangements are both fun to listen to and also very, very spiritual. Keep it up, and I’d love to hear some more electric arrangements! Thanks for the awesome music!
Ben Howington
Posted at 00:49h, 28 MayThanks so much! I’m with you. I learned to play on the electric and it’s always been the best way to express emotion. So yeah, I’m definitely working on incorporating it more. Thanks again!
Elder Garent
Posted at 15:19h, 19 Septemberhey Ben,
This is elder garent serving as a missionary in New mexico and i recently started playing guitar, i am super pumped to hear all the amazing and beautiful arrangements you bring forth. i feel the spirit so much and it helps me focus on the savior even more. thank you for all you do really appreciate it!
Tracy Ward
Posted at 22:07h, 01 DecemberI own your two albums and LOVE them. Two questions: how do I buy O Come, O Come Emmanuel and will you please do Come, Come Ye Saints? My little girl, Annesley, has been hoping you will do it for the past year. She is a huge fan and it is her favorite hymn.
Suzanne
Posted at 10:46h, 14 OctoberHi Ben,
My son is serving a mission (2019-2021) in Brazil and bought a guitar there to play to help decompress. He misses his guitar at home. I”m sending him some of your music via PDF but would love it if all of your music was available in PDF. Thanks! He loves your music!